CD break-even
Find out if breaking an old CD pays for itself.
Enter the balance, the penalty in months of interest, and the new APY. The result compares ending wealth if you stay with ending wealth if you move.
Time horizon
Interest given up at the big bank
$1,122.50
Over 1 year, $25,000 at 4.50% earns $1,125. The same path at 0.01% earns $2.50. Deposits are added at the end of each month, and the gap is interest only.
- HYSA interest
- $1,125
- Big bank interest
- $2.50
Balance over time
HYSA Big bank
Rung 1
Rung 2
Rung 3
Rung 4
Blended APY
4.61%
If every rung is held to its own maturity date, the ladder earns $727.29 on $25,000. Those dollars do not arrive on the same day.
| Term | APY | Principal | Interest | At maturity |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 3 months | 4.40% | $6,250 | $67.64 | $6,317.64 |
| 6 months | 4.55% | $6,250 | $140.61 | $6,390.61 |
| 9 months | 4.70% | $6,250 | $219.04 | $6,469.04 |
| 1 year | 4.80% | $6,250 | $300 | $6,550 |
Break the CD?
Worth breaking+$335.83
The penalty is $125, so $24,875 moves to the new rate. Over the 9 months still left, keeping the CD ends at $25,374.07. Moving ends at $25,709.90. The new rate catches up in 2.5 months.
- Keep current CD
- $25,374.07
- Pay penalty and move
- $25,709.90
Penalty uses the simple formula: balance × current APY × penalty months / 12. Ending balances compound the APY over the months remaining.
Federal tax bracket
Which product are you holding?
After-tax yield on your pick
3.19%
$25,000 at a 4.50% quote pays $1,125 before tax and $798.75 after the rates entered here. This is a flat estimate. It ignores deductions, brackets inside a bracket, and the net investment income tax.
HYSA or CD, after tax
3.19%
$798.75 a year
T-bill, state tax exempt
3.42%
$855 a year
The same APY in a Treasury bill keeps $56.25 more per year because state income tax does not apply.
Sample partner rates
Annual interest at each sample APY on $25,000.
Partner Bank A
High-yield savings
$1,162.50/ year
Sample HYSA. Not a live offer.
Partner Bank B
12-month CD
$1,187.50/ year
Sample certificate of deposit. Not a live offer.
CD Marketplace C
No-penalty CD
$1,200/ year
Sample no-penalty CD. Not a live offer.
Treasury Platform D
Treasury bill
$1,150/ year
Sample T-bill rate. Treasury bills are not FDIC insured.